Center for Peace and War Studies مرکز مطالعات صلح و جنگ

US and the War

NATO Membership for Ukraine Floated in Peace Talks

admin
Volodymyr Zelensky with King Willem-Alexander and Queen Maxima at the NATO Summit 2025 dinner in The Hague
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky (right) is greeted by King Willem-Alexander and Queen Maxima at a dinner at Huis ten Bosch Palace during the NATO Summit 2025 in The Hague, 24 June 2025. Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Ministerie van Buitenlandse Zaken

Full text

The Wall Street Journal reported that over the past few months, in closed-door peace talks, Jared Kushner, the president’s son-in-law and special envoy, has discussed an idea long considered dead on arrival: NATO membership for Ukraine if it cedes territory to Russia. Moscow has fought for years to keep Ukraine out of the 32-member alliance, and Trump himself ruled out membership early last year as unacceptable to Russia.

According to people familiar with the talks, the idea has come up in several conversations between European officials and the two American envoys. Most recently, Kushner discussed it last week at a military airfield in Dublin, in a meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, his adviser Rustem Umerov and selected European national security advisers. It also came up in meetings in the United Arab Emirates and in phone calls as early as August.

Washington has put two scenarios on the table. Under the first, Ukraine would give up the part of the eastern Donbas region it still controls in exchange for full NATO membership. Under the second, the front line would be frozen where it stands, leaving part of the Donbas in Ukrainian hands, and Kyiv would receive security guarantees against a future Russian assault through an international treaty with the United States and potentially European allies. Speaking in Berlin on Thursday, Kushner said Moscow had grown comfortable with NATO-like guarantees for Ukraine and spoke of huge deterrence and massive consequences if they were ever violated.

Zelensky has confirmed that the Americans raised the NATO question, and said any deal would need approval by the Ukrainian people. He has also repeated that Ukraine is not retreating and will not give up its land. On the other side, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said on Friday that any quasi-membership for Ukraine in NATO would be unacceptable. Russian negotiators in Abu Dhabi demanded that Ukraine strip its NATO aspirations from its constitution, that Western arms deliveries stop, and that the alliance roll back its military infrastructure in Eastern Europe to 1997 levels.

In Berlin, French President Emmanuel Macron raised advancing Ukraine’s NATO bid, but German Chancellor Friedrich Merz opposed it, telling aides Ukraine would not join the alliance in his lifetime.

Background: Ukraine’s NATO membership has been Moscow’s central red line since the start of the war, and Washington avoided it for fear of drawing the West into direct confrontation with Russia. That Trump’s envoys are now floating it shows how far the White House may be willing to go to break the stalemate in the talks.

Analysis: The proposal is, above all, an instrument of pressure on the Kremlin. The prospect of Kyiv inside NATO is the outcome Moscow fears most, and Washington has now placed it openly on the table. The war against the Islamic Republic has shown the same pattern: coordinated military and economic pressure, backed by political will, changes an adversary’s calculations. Used well, this lever forces Russia to choose between a grinding war of attrition and a settlement that locks in Ukraine’s security.

Source: Wall Street Journal