In an analysis released on Friday, the Congressional Budget Office found that selling Virginia-class attack submarines to Australia would reduce the number of attack submarines available to the US Navy for many years. Under Pillar One of AUKUS, the United States has agreed to sell Australia between three and five in-service Virginia-class boats beginning in 2032.
The US submarine industrial base, the CBO found, is already struggling to meet the Navy’s own demand. American yards are producing Virginia-class submarines at a rate of about 1.13 a year, when two a year are needed just for US requirements and 2.33 a year to have additional boats for Australia. Construction that took five to six years in the 2000s now averages 10 to 11 years, with deliveries running 24 to 36 months late.
The office’s second doubt is political and operational. Australia would control its own submarines, and their participation in any particular conflict would not be guaranteed. Australia’s defence minister said in 2023 that Canberra would make no promises to deploy its boats in support of a US conflict with China. The CBO asked whether China would be less deterred if the United States cut its own attack submarine numbers to build up Australia’s force. Against that, it accepted that Australian boats based in the Western Pacific could respond more quickly to a crisis over Taiwan or in the South China Sea, and that the robust alliance could offset part of the loss.
US law keeps the decision in Washington’s hands: a transfer is allowed only if it will not degrade American undersea capability, and the United States can refuse without penalty. The Congressional Research Service has previously raised an alternative division of labour in which the submarines stay under US command and operate from Australian bases.
Background: AUKUS is the backbone of the allied effort to strengthen undersea deterrence against China, but its bottleneck is industrial capacity rather than political will. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth affirmed US support for the pact in a September meeting with his Australian counterpart.
Analysis: The CBO warning is about pace, not about the pact itself. China’s undersea threat is real and growing, and the answer is the combined submarine weight of the United States, Britain and Australia. But an alliance on paper is not enough. Until American submarine production rises, every boat transferred to an ally is a boat subtracted from the US fleet. The report’s lesson for Washington is plain: the industrial base has to move at the speed of the strategy.
Source: The Guardian
